The Ongoing Debate: London's Oldest Riverside Pub
Competition over historical distinction: Two riverside pubs in London lay claim to being the city's oldest
The riverside of London is home to two pubs that have been vying for the title of the oldest for centuries - the Prospect of Whitby and the Mayflower.
The Prospect of Whitby, with its roots dating back to 1520, is the oldest pub in London with documented history spanning over 500 years [3][5]. Known for its rich heritage, this pub has been a favourite among notable figures such as Charles Dickens and Samuel Pepys. The pub's pewter bar, the longest of its kind in Britain, serves as a reminder of its long history.
However, the Prospect of Whitby's claim to fame is not without controversy. It was once known as the Devil's Tavern due to its association with thieves and smugglers [6]. The infamous "Hanging Judge Jeffreys" is said to have watched hangings at the nearby "Execution Dock" from the pub's pewter bar.
On the other hand, the Mayflower, named after the Pilgrim Mayflower ship, was established at its current location in 1957. However, the site has a rich history dating back to 1620, when the Mayflower ship set sail from the location [1]. The pub claims to have some of the original timbers from the ship incorporated into its structure.
While the Prospect of Whitby may have an older documented history, the Mayflower boasts a unique connection to a significant historical event. This has sparked a "loving rivalry" between the two pubs, each claiming to be the oldest riverside pub in London [2].
However, the title remains unofficial due to the complexities created by numerous name changes, relocations, and reconstructions of pubs in London [4]. English historian and author Jacob Field stated that many pubs have changed names over time, making it difficult to claim they are the oldest [7].
Despite the ongoing debate, both pubs continue to attract visitors with their traditional British fare and atmospheres. The search for the oldest pub in London continues, but for now, the title remains a point of friendly competition between the Prospect of Whitby and the Mayflower.
References:
- BBC News
- The Telegraph
- Time Out London
- The Guardian
- The Prospect of Whitby
- The Mayflower
- Jacob Field
- Visitors to London can explore the food-and-drink scene by dining at the Prospect of Whitby, a pub rooted in the city since 1520, or the Mayflower, named after the Pilgrim ship and with origins dating back to 1620.
- Social-media platforms are abuzz with discussions about the two pubs, fueling a 'loving rivalry' as they both stake a claim to being the oldest riverside pub in London.
- The entertainment industry often features both pubs in documentaries and shows, highlighting their significant roles in pop-culture and European histories.
- As the premier league of football unfolds each season, football fans flock to these pubs to catch matches, adding another layer to the rich sports culture that surrounds them.
- Home-and-garden enthusiasts might appreciate the historic charm of the pubs' interiors, with original timbers from ships and the longest pewter bar in Britain in the case of the Prospect of Whitby.
- For car aficionados, these pubs offer a glimpse into London's past, providing a unique connection to the city's history amidst the ever-evolving landscape of travel and transportation.
